Chapter 9: CFA Level 1 Financial Statement Analysis
Understanding deferred tax accounting and effective tax rate analysis
A company's financial statements are prepared using accounting principles (like IFRS or U.S. GAAP), while its tax obligations are determined by tax laws set by the government. These two sets of rules are often different, leading to discrepancies between the profit a company reports to investors and the income on which it actually pays taxes.
Understanding the following core terms is essential for income tax analysis:
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Accounting Profit | The pre-tax profit reported on a company's income statement, calculated according to accounting standards (IFRS/GAAP). |
| Taxable Income | The profit subject to income tax, calculated according to the rules set by tax authorities. This is the amount used to determine the actual tax payable for the period. |
| Tax Expense | The total tax reported on the income statement. It includes both the current tax payable and changes in deferred tax assets/liabilities. |
| Taxes Payable | The actual amount of tax that a company must pay to the tax authorities for the current period. |
| Deferred Taxes | The difference between the tax expense and the tax payable, arising from timing differences. |
| Temporary Differences | Differences between the carrying amount of an asset or liability on the balance sheet and its tax base. These differences will reverse in future periods. |
| Permanent Differences | Differences between accounting and tax rules that will never reverse. Examples include non-deductible expenses or non-taxable income. |
The official corporate income tax rate enacted by law in a specific jurisdiction.
This represents the company's actual tax burden on its reported profit.
Deferred taxes arise from temporary differences between accounting profit and taxable income. They represent future tax effects of transactions that have already been recognized in the financial statements.
Core Idea: The goal of deferred tax accounting is to match the tax expense with the accounting profit in the period it is earned, regardless of when the tax is actually paid.
| Feature | Deferred Tax Liability (DTL) | Deferred Tax Asset (DTA) |
|---|---|---|
| What is it? | An obligation to pay more tax in the future. | A right to pay less tax in the future. |
| When does it arise? | When accounting profit is less than taxable income now, but will be higher in the future. This happens when:
|
When accounting profit is greater than taxable income now, but will be lower in the future. This happens when:
|
| Common Causes |
Accelerated Depreciation for Tax:
A company gets larger tax deductions for an asset upfront than the depreciation expense it reports on its income statement.
Unrealized Gains:
Gains on investments are reported on the income statement but are not taxed until the investment is sold. |
Warranty Expenses:
A company estimates and expenses future warranty costs on its income statement, but can only deduct them for tax purposes when the costs are actually paid.
Unrealized Losses:
Losses on investments are reported on the income statement but are not tax-deductible until the investment is sold.
Tax Loss Carryforwards:
When a company has a net loss for tax purposes, it can often use that loss to reduce taxable income in future years. |
| Effect on Future Taxes | Increases future taxes payable | Decreases future taxes payable |
Important: While DTLs are generally always recognized, a DTA is only recognized if it is probable that the company will have sufficient future taxable profit to actually use the asset (i.e., to realize the future tax deduction). This involves management judgment about future profitability.
If it's not probable that a DTA will be realized, a valuation allowance is created as a contra-asset. Increases in the valuation allowance signal deteriorating profit expectations and increase tax expense.
Analysts use different tax rates to evaluate a company's earnings and cash flows:
| Tax Rate | How to Calculate | What it Tells an Analyst |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory Tax Rate | The official rate in the company's home country. | The baseline rate before any adjustments. A starting point for analysis. |
| Effective Tax Rate |
Effective Tax Rate = Tax Expense ÷ Pre-Tax Income
|
Shows the actual tax burden on reported profits. It is crucial for forecasting future earnings. A rate consistently different from the statutory rate requires investigation. |
| Cash Tax Rate |
Cash Tax Rate = Cash Taxes Paid ÷ Pre-Tax Income
|
Measures the actual cash that went out the door for taxes. This is vital for cash flow modeling and valuation. |
Analysis Note: The effective tax rate often differs from the statutory rate due to factors like tax credits, permanent differences, and different tax rates in various countries where the company operates (geographic mix of profits).
Requires companies to present DTAs and DTLs as separate line items. It also requires a breakdown of components and their recovery timing (e.g., reversing in more or less than 12 months).
Generally classifies all DTAs and DTLs as non-current on the balance sheet.
A company can only present a single net deferred tax asset or liability if specific conditions are met:
Companies must provide a reconciliation to explain why their reported income tax expense is different from the amount that would result from applying the statutory tax rate to their accounting profit.
Income taxes typically account for 2-3 questions on the CFA Level I exam. Focus on:
where Δ = Change in deferred tax asset or liability during the period
Shows actual tax burden on reported profits
Actual cash tax owed to tax authorities
DTL when accounting income < taxable income; DTA when accounting income > taxable income
More relevant for cash flow modeling than ETR